Obara found guilty but not in Blackman case
Posted by Sean at 06:22, April 24th, 2007Joji Obara, accused of murdering hostess Lucie Blackman in 2000, has now been tried and sentenced:
A Tokyo court on Tuesday sentenced businessman Joji Obara to life in prison for drugging and raping nine women, including an Australian who died, but acquitted him in the death of Briton Lucie Blackman.
The Tokyo District Court said prosecutors failed to provide evidence that proves Obara, 54, was responsible for the death of the 21-year-old British hostess whose dismembered body was found in Kanagawa Prefecture in 2001.
…
Prosecutors used as evidence videotapes seized from Obara’s home that showed him attacking the nine victims.
But there was no such footage of Blackman on the tapes.
In fact, prosecutors’ arguments concerning the Blackman case were based largely on circumstantial evidence.
Even the cause of her death has not been established.
Prosecutors argued that Obara was seen with Blackman just before she went missing, and that the same type of cement used to encase her head was found in Obara’s room.
But the judge said these pieces of evidence do not show to what degree Obara was involved in Blackman’s death.
…
The judge concluded, “Doubts remain over whether the criminal actions were carried out solely by the defendant.”
I can see how the Blackman family would be unsatisfied with the verdict, but it doesn’t seem unjustified. Obara’s story (the Mainichi has a Japanese report here) is that an acquaintance of his, now conveniently dead, was the one who assaulted and killed Blackman and disposed of her corpse. I don’t buy it, but it certainly could have happened that way.
Of course, one can imagine political reasons for the verdict. There were widely-aired accusations that the police had been slow to investigate and, once on the case, slow and slipshod. The court’s decision doesn’t disprove that, but it makes it possible to take a position along the lines of, “See? Even when the police were forced to investigate thoroughly, they didn’t find enough evidence to convict Obara, so perhaps their original judgment calls weren’t so baseless after all.”